Proposalreviews

This collection contains reviews of funding proposals

Schema

The following lists key names mapped to its type and meaning for each entry.

_id:

[‘string’, ‘integer’, ‘float’], ID, e.g. 1906_doe_example, required

adequacy_of_resources:

list, Are the resources of the PI adequate, required

agency:

string, currently nsf, doe or other, optional

Allowed values:

• nsf

• doe

• other

competency_of_team:

list, Is the team competent, required

doe_appropriateness_of_approach:

list, Appropriateness of Research. only used if agency is doe., optional

doe_reasonableness_of_budget:

list, Reasonableness of budget. only used if agency is doe., optional

doe_relevance_to_program_mission:

list, Relevance to program mission. only used if agency is doe., optional

does_how:

list, How will the research be done, required

does_what:

string, What will the team do, required

due_date:

[‘string’, ‘date’], date the review is due in ISO format, required

freewrite:

[‘string’, ‘list’], Anything and this will appear in the built documentright before the summary. This section often used for extra review criteria for the particular proposal, optional

goals:

list, What are the main goals of the proposed research, required

importance:

list, The importance of the Research, required

institutions:

[‘string’, ‘list’], The institutions of the authors in the same order, required

month:

[‘string’, ‘integer’], The month the review was submitted, required

names:

[‘list’, ‘string’], The names of the PIs, required

nsf_broader_impacts:

list, The broader impacts of the research. Only used if agency is nsf, optional

nsf_create_original_transformative:

list, Answer to the question how the work is creative, original or transformative. Only used if agency is nsf, optional

nsf_plan_good:

list, Is the plan good? Only used if agency is nsf, optional

nsf_pot_to_advance_knowledge:

list, Answer to the question how the work will advanceknowledge. Only used if agency is nsf, optional

nsf_pot_to_benefit_society:

list, Answer to the question how the work has the potentialto benefit society. Only used if agency is nsf, optional

requester:

string, Name of the program officer who requested the review, required

reviewer:

string, short name of the reviewer. Will be used in the filename of the resulting text file, required

status:

string, the status of the review, optional

Allowed values:

• invited

• accepted

• declined

• downloaded

• inprogress

• submitted

• cancelled

summary:

string, Summary statement, required

title:

string, The title of the proposal, required

year:

integer, The year the review was submitted, required

YAML Example

1906doeExample:
  adequacy_of_resources:
    - The resources available to the PI seem adequate
  agency: doe
  competency_of_team:
    - super competent!
  doe_appropriateness_of_approach:
    - The proposed approach is highly innovative
  doe_reasonableness_of_budget:
    - They could do it with half the money
  doe_relevance_to_program_mission:
    - super relevant
  does_how:
    - they will find the cause of Malaria
    - when they find it they will determine a cure
  does_what: Find a cure for Malaria
  due_date: '2020-04-10'
  freewrite:
    - I can put extra things here, such as special instructions from the
    - program officer
  goals:
    - The goals of the proposal are to put together a team to find a cure for Malaria,
      and then to find it
  importance:
    - save lives
    - lift people from poverty
  institutions: columbiau
  month: May
  names:
    - B. Cause
    - A.N. Effect
  nsf_broader_impacts: []
  nsf_create_original_transformative: []
  nsf_plan_good: []
  nsf_pot_to_advance_knowledge: []
  nsf_pot_to_benefit_society: []
  requester: Lane Wilson
  reviewer: sbillinge
  status: submitted
  summary: dynamite proposal
  title: A stunning new way to cure Malaria
  year: 2019
1906nsfExample:
  adequacy_of_resources:
    - The resources available to the PI seem adequate
  agency: nsf
  competency_of_team:
    - super competent!
  doe_appropriateness_of_approach: []
  doe_reasonableness_of_budget: []
  doe_relevance_to_program_mission: []
  does_how:
    - they will find the cause of Poverty
    - when they find it they will determine a cure
  does_what: Find a cure for Poverty
  due_date: '2020-04-10'
  freewrite: I can put extra things here, such as special instructions from the
  goals:
    - The goals of the proposal are to put together a team to find a cure for Poverty,
      and then to find it
  importance:
    - save lives
    - lift people from poverty
  institutions: []
  month: May
  names:
    - A Genius
  nsf_broader_impacts:
    - Poor people will be made unpoor
  nsf_create_original_transformative:
    - transformative because lives will be transformed
  nsf_plan_good:
    - I don't see any issues with the plan
    - it should be very straightforward
  nsf_pot_to_advance_knowledge:
    - This won't advance knowledge at all
  nsf_pot_to_benefit_society:
    - Society will benefit by poor people being made unpoor if they want to be
  requester: Tessemer Guebre
  reviewer: sbillinge
  status: submitted
  summary: dynamite proposal
  title: A stunning new way to cure Poverty
  year: 2019

JSON/Mongo Example

{
    "_id": "1906doeExample",
    "adequacy_of_resources": [
        "The resources available to the PI seem adequate"
    ],
    "agency": "doe",
    "competency_of_team": [
        "super competent!"
    ],
    "doe_appropriateness_of_approach": [
        "The proposed approach is highly innovative"
    ],
    "doe_reasonableness_of_budget": [
        "They could do it with half the money"
    ],
    "doe_relevance_to_program_mission": [
        "super relevant"
    ],
    "does_how": [
        "they will find the cause of Malaria",
        "when they find it they will determine a cure"
    ],
    "does_what": "Find a cure for Malaria",
    "due_date": "2020-04-10",
    "freewrite": [
        "I can put extra things here, such as special instructions from the",
        "program officer"
    ],
    "goals": [
        "The goals of the proposal are to put together a team to find a cure for Malaria, and then to find it"
    ],
    "importance": [
        "save lives",
        "lift people from poverty"
    ],
    "institutions": "columbiau",
    "month": "May",
    "names": [
        "B. Cause",
        "A.N. Effect"
    ],
    "nsf_broader_impacts": [],
    "nsf_create_original_transformative": [],
    "nsf_plan_good": [],
    "nsf_pot_to_advance_knowledge": [],
    "nsf_pot_to_benefit_society": [],
    "requester": "Lane Wilson",
    "reviewer": "sbillinge",
    "status": "submitted",
    "summary": "dynamite proposal",
    "title": "A stunning new way to cure Malaria",
    "year": 2019
}
{
    "_id": "1906nsfExample",
    "adequacy_of_resources": [
        "The resources available to the PI seem adequate"
    ],
    "agency": "nsf",
    "competency_of_team": [
        "super competent!"
    ],
    "doe_appropriateness_of_approach": [],
    "doe_reasonableness_of_budget": [],
    "doe_relevance_to_program_mission": [],
    "does_how": [
        "they will find the cause of Poverty",
        "when they find it they will determine a cure"
    ],
    "does_what": "Find a cure for Poverty",
    "due_date": "2020-04-10",
    "freewrite": "I can put extra things here, such as special instructions from the",
    "goals": [
        "The goals of the proposal are to put together a team to find a cure for Poverty, and then to find it"
    ],
    "importance": [
        "save lives",
        "lift people from poverty"
    ],
    "institutions": [],
    "month": "May",
    "names": [
        "A Genius"
    ],
    "nsf_broader_impacts": [
        "Poor people will be made unpoor"
    ],
    "nsf_create_original_transformative": [
        "transformative because lives will be transformed"
    ],
    "nsf_plan_good": [
        "I don't see any issues with the plan",
        "it should be very straightforward"
    ],
    "nsf_pot_to_advance_knowledge": [
        "This won't advance knowledge at all"
    ],
    "nsf_pot_to_benefit_society": [
        "Society will benefit by poor people being made unpoor if they want to be"
    ],
    "requester": "Tessemer Guebre",
    "reviewer": "sbillinge",
    "status": "submitted",
    "summary": "dynamite proposal",
    "title": "A stunning new way to cure Poverty",
    "year": 2019
}